This article explores the ITAT Delhi’s decision on ITA No.527/Del/2021 involving Mentor Graphics Ireland Ltd. for the assessment year 2017-18, addressing the contentious issue of whether payments received for software distribution should be taxed as royalty in India.
Mentor Graphics Ireland Ltd., headquartered in Ireland, contested the Indian tax authorities’ decision to tax the income from their software products sold in India as ‘royalty’ under the India-Ireland Double Taxation Avoidance Agreement (DTAA) and the Indian Income Tax Act, 1961. The case challenges the interpretation of payments related to copyrighted software products distributed in India.
The core of the dispute lies in whether the payments received by the company for its software products qualify as royalty. The assessing officer, guided by the Dispute Resolution Panel (DRP), treated these payments as royalty, which was contested by Mentor Graphics, arguing that the payments were for the sale of software products and not for the license of copyrights.
The tribunal reviewed several precedents, including the landmark Supreme Court ruling in the case of Engineering Analysis Centre of Excellence Private Limited, which clarified the taxation of software payments. The Supreme Court had determined that such payments do not constitute royalty if there is no transfer of copyright as per the terms of the DTAA between India and Ireland. The ITAT followed this precedent and directed the assessing officer to delete the addition made under the guise of royalty payments.
The tribunal’s decision underscores the importance of understanding the nature of transactions involving software and the implications of international agreements on tax obligations. This case highlights the evolving landscape of software taxation and sets a significant precedent for similar disputes involving multinational companies operating in India.
Order pronounced in the open court on June 21, 2023.
Royalty Tax Dispute for Mentor Graphics Ireland Ltd. in Assessment Year 2017-18
Manage the increasing number of hearings effortlessly by leveraging the legal AI revolution We are India's Leading revolutionary AI-powered legal platform where you can get enough insights into top cases and judgements.
Research Platform