This detailed article reviews the tax dispute between Sheraton International LLC and the Joint Commissioner of Income Tax, International Taxation, New Delhi, concerning the assessment year 2013-14. The case, ITA No. 4772/DEL/2019, centers on the assessment of centralized service fees related to sales, marketing, reservations, and loyalty programs conducted outside India.
The controversy arose from the addition of income amounting to Rs. 20,13,09,505 made by the assessing officer towards Centralized Services fees received by Sheraton International LLC. These fees were associated with various centralized services rendered outside India, which were assessed as ancillary to the license fee and connected to a business operation in India.
Sheraton International contested that these services did not constitute a business connection in India and were not ancillary or subsidiary to any license fee. The tribunal was tasked with deciding whether the income from these services should be taxable in India, considering the operations were conducted entirely outside Indian territory.
During the proceedings, it was contended that a substantial part of the profits was attributed to Indian operations without adequate justification, applying a profit percentage significantly higher than what might be considered reasonable under international tax norms.
The tribunal recognized that the appeal raised substantial questions regarding the application of international tax laws and the interpretation of tax treaties. The decision referenced previous rulings favorable to the appellant and acknowledged ongoing litigation at the Supreme Court level, emphasizing the need for consistency with higher judicial decisions.
Ultimately, the tribunal set aside the orders of lower tax authorities and decided in favor of Sheraton International, allowing the appeal for all related assessment years. This outcome highlights the complexities of international taxation and the critical role of judicial precedents in resolving such disputes.
The case of Sheraton International LLC vs JCIT represents a significant precedent in the domain of international tax law, particularly concerning the taxation of centralized services performed by multinational corporations outside India. The tribunal’s decision underscores the importance of adhering to established judicial principles and the proper application of tax treaties.
Manage the increasing number of hearings effortlessly by leveraging the legal AI revolution We are India's Leading revolutionary AI-powered legal platform where you can get enough insights into top cases and judgements.
Research Platform